Informed Consent For Any Sugery Must As No Surgery Have Zero Risk Of Death - Welcome To IndiaHeartBeat.Com India's Leading Online Doctor Directory, Live Help

World's first medical networking and resource portal

Community Weblogs

My Blog Browser Bookmark

Jul15

Informed Consent For Any Sugery Must As No Surgery Have Zero Risk Of Death

Dr.Dram,profdrram@gmail.com,Hiv,Hepatitis and sex diseases expert +917838059592,+919434143550

Now a days,few court judgements have made hospitals and doctors to pay lacs as compensation as Hospital or Doctor didnot take extensive consent explaining risk involved in an operation or procedure and it's comparison with other available procedures.Doctors mostly think it is routine or rare so why to waste time in detailing .

Patients or attenders after complications or during payments forget all morality and choose to sue Doctors or Hospitals for such laxacity ,no verbal but written,not once but even after Operation if pt needs more stay or treatment repeated consent on day to day progress should be taken as patients or attendeds can't claim they donot know what happened or Doctors told everthing fine but death or complications occcued or charges not told before.

Even few patients sue doctors for publicity,extracting money on advice of different NGO or Lawyers partner with patient to fight their case free and sharing in recovery from Hospitals.Althoug advances in surgical techniques, training, anesthesia, instruments, diagnostic equipment have greatly reduces the mortality associated with a surgery, every surgery carries a risk of death. Death associated with anesthetic procedures is 1-4 deaths per 10,000 anesthesias. The in-hospital mortality rates for hip fractures range from 1-10%. In patients undergoing cardiac bypass surgery, mortality is 2-5% for all patients and about 1% for the lowest-risk elective patients. As per the American College of Surgeons, one of 1,000 patients die during a cholecystectomy. Mortality in hysterectomy from 0.6 to 1.6 per 1000 procedures. Post-appendectomy mortality rate at 30 days is reported to be 2.1 per 1000.

Several factors affect the risk of death. These may be related to the surgical procedure itself, anesthesia, drugs, age of the patient, general condition of the patient, medical history of the patient (comorbidities), the type of surgery, experience of the surgeon performing the surgery. Factors like what day of the week the surgery is done or time of surgery, whether night time or during the day also influence the risk of death.

Evidence has shown that patients who undergo surgery over the weekend or at night have a greater likelihood of dying after the surgery. Patients undergoing surgery can be categorized as low risk patients whose estimated risk of death is less than 1% and high risk patients, whose estimated risk of death is more than 1%. No surgery therefore can be said to be risk-free.

There is always a risk of death in every surgical procedure, even in a minor surgery. The doctor is bound to inform the patient and the family about the risk of death with the surgery (along with other relevant information), even if the patient is low-risk. This enables patients to make informed decision about whether they should avoid the surgery or choose to undergo the procedure, whether the benefits of the surgery are worth the risks.

The Montgomery judgement of the UK Supreme Court precisely addressed this aspect of informed consent, when it ruled that the doctor has a duty “to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks involved in any recommended treatment, and of any reasonable alternative or variant treatments”. Material risk is the risk which a reasonable person would consider significant or a risk which a doctor knows (or should reasonably know) that the patient would consider it to be significant.

The judgement further said, “the “therapeutic exception” is not intended to enable doctors to prevent their patients from taking an informed decision. Rather, it is the doctor’s responsibility to explain to her patient why she considers that one of the available treatment options is medically preferable to the others, having taken care to ensure that her patient is aware of the considerations for and against each of them.”

Posted on Sunday, 15th July 2018